Off-Market Properties: Are They Really a Better Deal? | Property Home Base
Buyer guide

Off-Market Properties Are Not Always Better

Many buyers chase off-market homes as a secret VIP deal. Sometimes they are. A lot of the time off-market quietly works against the buyer.

By Property Home Base · 4 minute read

THE SHORT ANSWER

An off-market property can be a great result, but off-market does not automatically mean bargain. With no open competition setting the price, you rely on your own research to know if it is fair. What protects you is knowing the true value before you offer, on-market or off.

PART 1

What Does Off-Market Mean?

An off-market property is a property that's for sale, or it could be testing the market, but is not openly advertised on the property portals. It may be offered quietly to a small number of buyers, or never publicly listed at all. Agents sometimes call this a pocket listing or an off-market sale.

Vendors choose it for different reasons: privacy, avoiding a long public campaign, testing the market, or sparing a home from open inspections.

PART 2

What Is the Appeal of Off-Market?

  • ✓Less competition: fewer buyers means less chance of a bidding war
  • ✓No public campaign: no crowd at an auction and no open inspection pressure
  • ✓More time: you may be able to inspect and negotiate privately
  • ✓Genuine opportunity: sometimes a vendor wants a quick, quiet and certain sale, and a prepared buyer can benefit

For the right buyer, a genuine off-market purchase can be a very good result.

PART 3

What Are the Risks?

Without a property being openly on the market, how do you know it is priced fairly? Competition normally helps set the price. Off-market, that is missing, so you rely entirely on your own research.

Sometimes there is a reason a property is off-market. It might have sat unsold, or the seller may be testing a high price quietly before committing to a full campaign. Off-market can mean less scrutiny, not a bargain.

On-market compared with off-market
On-MarketOff-Market
CompetitionOpen and publicOften less
Price discoveryCompetition helps set the priceYou rely on your own research
ScrutinyHighCan be lower
Main riskPaying more in the heat of a campaignPaying a fair-looking price that is not supported by evidence
What protects youComparable sales and a firm limitThe same: know the true value before you offer
PART 4

How Do Buyers Find Off-Market Properties?

Most off-market opportunities come through relationships with local agents. Agents hear about owners who may sell, and they call buyers they trust. A Buyer's Agent contacts local agents on your behalf as part of the search, and is known to the agents in the areas they buy in.

  • ✓Tell local agents what you are looking for, and be ready to move
  • ✓Register with agents in your target suburbs
  • ✓Work with an Advocate who has relationships in those suburbs
  • ✓Be realistic about price, because the vendor wants a fair result

We buy in every suburb across greater Melbourne, and around 12% to 15% of our purchases are off-market.

PART 5

How Do You Make Sure an Off-Market Price Is Fair?

  1. 1Value the property against recent comparable sales, exactly as you would an advertised property
  2. 2Ask why it is off-market and how long it has been available
  3. 3Do the same due diligence as any other purchase: contract, Section 32, building and pest
  4. 4Decide your limit from the evidence, not from the fear of missing out
  5. 5Be ready to walk away if the numbers do not stack up
Our approach

We only recommend an off-market property when it is a good opportunity, and we do not overpay just to buy something off-market.

CHECKLIST

Off-Market Checklist

  • ✓Comparable sales researched for the same type, size and location
  • ✓Reason for off-market asked, and how long it has been available
  • ✓Contract and Section 32 reviewed
  • ✓Building and pest report completed
  • ✓A limit decided before negotiating
  • ✓Compared against what an advertised version would sell for

Common Questions

Are off-market properties cheaper?

Not necessarily. With less competition the price can be lower, but there is also less price discovery. Value it against comparable sales before you offer.

How do buyers find off-market properties?

Mostly through relationships with local agents. A Buyer’s Agent contacts local agents on your behalf to find properties before they are advertised.

Should I only look for off-market properties?

No. A property that is properly priced and well-run on-market can be just as good. Look at all options and let the value decide.

Do you charge more for off-market purchases?

No. Our fees are flat and the same whether the property is on-market or off-market. See our fees.

Related

Buyer’s Agent ServicesSearch, off-market access and negotiation.Due Diligence Before BuyingWhat to check before you commit.FeesFlat fees from $2,200.What Is a Buyer’s Agent?What a Buyer’s Agent does and how they are paid.Auction vs Private SaleHow each sale method works.Case Study: Finding OpportunityHow regular agent outreach uncovered an off-market home.